I agree. Super Mario 3D World (Wii U) and The Legend Of Zelda: A Link Between Worlds (3DS) are looking to be must-plays. A sequel to my favourite Zelda game? YES PLEASE! But despite being a Zelda fan, I did not pick up Wind Waker HD, or at least not yet. I thoroughly enjoyed the original on the GameCube, and this one has some revisions but very few actual additions. Not to say I won't ever play it, but right now I am playing too much and foreseeing more games on the horizon that to essentially replay a game is not really priority.
As for the decision you are making, Rew, I recommend Super Mario RPG: Legend Of The Seven Stars. Of those three, that seems the most like a must-play. (Surprising that you haven't played it already!) I enjoyed Kid Icarus: Uprising, and it was longer than I expected, but I didn't ever get serious about the multiplayer. And speaking of Wario, I started Wario Land 4 (GBA) a number of times but never finished it, or even got very far. I'm now close to doing so, having played it on the 3DS on boring commutes (thanks to it being one of the "3DS Ambassador" free games) - I have collected all the CDs and pretty much just have to defeat the final boss, but I've lost a few times...it's been a pain because for whatever reason I have been having trouble with all the bosses in this game. I only used items to help against one of the bosses so far (I think) and just saving up enough points to get an item is a pain too (silly mini-games, sigh). But thanks for reminding me that I should probably finish that, too. And back to speaking of Mario RPGs not played...somehow Paper Mario: Sticker Star (3DS) and Mario & Luigi: Dream Team (3DS) slipped by me, oops. And I've enjoyed every Mario RPG so far. Does anyone recommend that I should play either one before the other? I feel like I might get muddled up if I play two RPGs concurrently, especially featuring similar characters despite being different continuities.
Meanwhile, my main focus right now is Pokémon Y (3DS) - I think I'm about halfway through the story, and my brother is playing X, working on mastering my Level 6 Infinity Blade in Infinity Blade III (iOS) - funny how I got into all three Infinity Blade games so seriously when not that long ago I thought any app games were silly >_> - oh yeah and I have gotten all but two of the objectives in Temple Run 2 (iOS) >_>... Forgot that I'm only halfway through Mortal Kombat: Komplete Edition (PC)...should get back to that too.
Anyone with a 3DS should get all those StreetPass Mii Plaza (3DS) games...so addicting. I'm far (well, compared to most people) in all four games in that. Thankfully besides my brother and a co-worker there are usually also people I StreetPass tag on the commute to and from work.
Soon, there are those Wii U and 3DS games I'm looking forward to, already mentioned. Also the upcoming Phoenix Wright: Dual Destinies (3DS) and Professor Layton and the Azran Legacy (3DS)...I'm sure there's other stuff I'm forgetting that I'm playing or looking forward to. Oh yes, Just Dance 2014 (Wii U) - don't laugh - is good for daily cardio. Makes me contemplate if Wii Fit U (Wii U) is worth dusting off the old Balance Board for. I'm not fat but it wouldn't hurt to lose a few pounds or be a little more fit.
Ah yes, and LEGO Marvel Super Heroes (Wii U/PC) comes out next week...aagh, always too much to play.